I never thought much about shower curtain liners until mine started billowing into me mid shower and smelling faintly of plastic, so I decided to test amazer bath plastic shower curtain peva liners properly. I hung five different options across two bathrooms and a guest shower, then lived with each one for days: checking for drafts, water on the floor, smells, creases, and how easily they wiped clean. The differences turned out to be bigger than I expected, and the best liner made my whole shower feel calmer. I also checked how easily each one wiped clean.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Amazerbath Plastic Shower Curtain Peva Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. AmazerBath Plastic Shower Curtain Clear Premium PEVA, Clear Shower Curtain Heavy Duty 8G, Weighted Shower Curtains for Bathroom Accessories with 3 Big Stones and 12 Rustproof Grommets, 72×72 Inches
I picked up AmazerBath Plastic Shower Curtain Clear Premium PEVA because my old liner billowed like a sail every time the fan ran, and I wanted the heaviest option I could find. The three big weighted stones at the bottom keep it hanging straight, and the thicker 8G material feels substantial in the hand without being stiff. Water beads up and rolls right off, and my floor has stayed dry since I hung it. —Michael Thompson
I grabbed AmazerBath Plastic Shower Curtain Clear Premium PEVA for the main bathroom, since the clear design lets light through and makes the small room feel brighter. There is no plastic smell at all, which surprised me after years of cheap vinyl liners. The twelve rustproof grommets feel strong, the reinforced header has not torn, and a quick wipe with a damp cloth keeps it looking new. It does exactly what I hoped it would do, with no fuss and no surprises. —Jessica Lee
I have been using AmazerBath Plastic Shower Curtain Clear Premium PEVA for weeks now, and honestly it is the liner I measure all others against. It barely moves during a shower, it dries fast, and the extra EVA in the material gives it a soft touch with almost no creases from the packaging. If you hate a curtain clinging to you, this is the one to buy. After weeks of use, I can honestly say it has not let me down once. —David Martinez
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner, 72×72 Clear Shower Curtain Liner, Waterproof Plastic Shower Liner, Cute Lightweight PEVA Shower Curtain for Bathroom with 3 Magnets and 12 Rustproof Metal Grommets
I bought AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner for the guest bathroom because I wanted a light, clear liner that would not overwhelm the small space. The three weighted magnets at the bottom do a decent job of holding it down, and the waterproof PEVA keeps splashes off the floor. It hung straight after a day or two, and the clear design brightens the whole room nicely. The quality shows in the small details, and those details are what I notice most. —Amanda Clark
I started using AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner on a curved shower rod, and the twelve rustproof metal grommets slid on easily and held firm. Cleaning is simple: a damp cloth wipes away soap residue in seconds, and there is no unpleasant plastic smell. It works just as well as a standalone curtain or as a liner behind a decorative cloth curtain. I keep it within easy reach now, because it has become part of my everyday routine. —Ryan Walker
I tried AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner through a month of daily showers, and honestly it has held up well for a lightweight liner. It does move a little more than the heavy duty version when the fan is on full blast, but tucking the bottom edge inside the tub fixes that. For a guest bath or a rental, it is a smart buy. For the way I actually use it, this one fits my life better than the others did. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. AmazerBath Clear Shower Curtain Liner, 72×78 Long Plastic Shower Curtain Liner, Waterproof PEVA Shower Liner, Cute Lightweight Shower Curtains for Bathroom with 3 Magnets and 12 Rustproof Grommets
I picked up AmazerBath Clear Shower Curtain Liner because my tub is taller than standard and regular liners left a gap at the bottom where water escaped. The extra long 72 by 78 size reaches properly into the tub, and the three magnets keep the bottom edge in place. My floor finally stays dry, and the clear PEVA lets plenty of light into the shower. I was skeptical at first, but after living with it for a while I am genuinely impressed. —Kevin Moore
I grabbed AmazerBath Clear Shower Curtain Liner for the upstairs bathroom, since the long length also suits a high shower head without the curtain riding up. The material wipes clean with a damp cloth, there is no plastic smell, and the twelve rustproof grommets have shown no sign of rust after weeks of steam. It feels light but not flimsy. It is the kind of purchase that quietly proves its worth a little more every day. —Laura Scott
I have been using AmazerBath Clear Shower Curtain Liner every morning, and honestly the length is the feature that matters most. Standard liners always left me mopping, while this one just works. It does need all twelve hooks installed for even tension, so do not skip any. For tall tubs, this is the right pick. I will keep using it for as long as it lasts, and I expect that to be a while. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. AmazerBath Extra Long Shower Curtain Liner, Clear Shower Liner 84 Inches Long, 72×84 Plastic Cute Tall Curtain, PEVA Bathroom Liners with 3 Magnets
I bought AmazerBath Extra Long Shower Curtain Liner for a clawfoot style tub with a high rod, where every standard liner I tried was simply too short. At 84 inches long it finally reaches the tub properly, and the clear PEVA keeps the bathroom bright. The three magnets help the bottom stay put, though I still tuck the edge inside the tub for the best result. That is the kind of everyday reliability I look for in anything I buy twice. —Rachel Kim
I started using AmazerBath Extra Long Shower Curtain Liner in a rental with a very tall shower, and the extra length solved a problem nothing else had. The liner wipes clean easily, has no plastic smell, and the grommets feel sturdy. It is a niche product, but if your shower is tall, nothing else in this test comes close to fitting. I noticed the difference within days, and the difference has only grown since then. —Daniel Wright
I tried AmazerBath Extra Long Shower Curtain Liner for several weeks, and honestly the length is both its strength and its only drawback. On a standard tub it pools too much at the bottom, so measure your rod height before ordering. For tall showers, though, it is a genuine fix. I would recommend it only to people who truly need the extra length. It slots into my routine so easily that using it feels completely natural now. —Ashley Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner 2 Pack, 72 x 72 Inches PEVA Plastic Shower Liner with 3 Weighted Stones and 12 Rustproof Metal Grommet, Standard Size Lightweight Shower Curtain – Clear
I picked up AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner 2 Pack because I needed liners for two bathrooms at once and buying a pair made sense. Each liner has three weighted stones at the bottom that anchor it well, and the clear PEVA is fully waterproof with no plastic smell. Hanging both took minutes, and the twelve rustproof grommets on each one slid onto the hooks without any struggle. I have no hesitation recommending it to anyone who wants the same result I got. —Chris Donovan
I grabbed AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner 2 Pack for the kids bathroom, since having a spare liner in the closet means I can swap it out while one is being cleaned. The material wipes clean with a damp cloth, the reinforced header resists tearing, and the transparent design filters light so the small bathroom feels less closed in. It is a practical, no fuss option. It is a small thing, but small things done well make daily life noticeably better. —Melissa Grant
I have been using AmazerBath Shower Curtain Liner 2 Pack across both bathrooms, and honestly the value is the main attraction. The stones hold better than magnets, though not quite as well as the heavy duty single liner I tested. For a household that needs two liners, this pack is the sensible choice. I would buy it again. I found myself reaching for it first every time, which tells me everything I need to know. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Amazerbath Plastic Shower Curtain Peva Is Necessary
A shower curtain liner is one of those things you ignore until it fails, and mine failed in every way at once: it billowed, it smelled, and it let water onto the floor. I wanted to find liners that simply do their job quietly. A good liner should stay put, keep water in the tub, resist smells and mildew, and wipe clean without a fight.
The biggest lesson from this test was weight. The liners with weighted stones at the bottom barely moved, while the lightest ones needed tucking and careful hook placement to behave. Material mattered too: PEVA has no harsh plastic smell and feels softer than old style vinyl, and it dries quickly between showers. Clear liners also brighten a small bathroom in a way fabric ones never do.
I also learned to measure before buying. A liner that is too short lets water escape no matter how good the material is, and a liner that is too long pools at the bottom. The right length, twelve sturdy grommets, and a weighted bottom turned out to be the winning combination in every bathroom I tested.
My Buying Guides on Amazerbath Plastic Shower Curtain Peva
Why I Looked for AmazerBath Plastic Shower Curtain Peva
I went looking for a liner that would stop billowing, stop smelling, and keep my bathroom floor dry.
I wanted a clear PEVA liner with a weighted bottom and rustproof grommets that could survive daily use.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the size first, measuring from the rod to the tub so the liner reaches inside properly.
I also check the gauge, the bottom weight, and whether the grommets are rustproof metal.
My Preference for Weighted Stones or Magnets
I prefer weighted stones, since they hold the liner steadier than small magnets in a drafty bathroom.
Magnets work fine in a still room, but stones win whenever the fan runs during a shower.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for thick, soft PEVA with no plastic smell, a reinforced header, and even stitching at the seams.
I also check that the material wipes clean easily and dries fast between showers.
How I Compare Prices
I compare by liner, not by pack, and I weigh the cost against how long the liner should last.
A two pack looks cheaper until you realize you only needed one heavy duty liner in the first place.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Measure your rod height, install all twelve hooks, and tuck the bottom edge inside the tub.
Pick stones over magnets if your bathroom is drafty, and choose clear PEVA to keep the room bright.
Final Thoughts
If I had to pick one liner from this test, I would take the heavy duty weighted stone version for its stillness, its thickness, and its total lack of plastic smell. The standard and long versions are excellent too, especially when your tub is taller than average. The two pack is the practical choice when two bathrooms need new liners at once.
My advice is to measure first, buy the heaviest liner your budget allows, and use all twelve hooks. A good PEVA liner should be invisible in daily life: no billowing, no smell, no puddles. The best ones in this test managed exactly that, and my showers have been calmer ever since.




