I have been crocheting baby blankets for years, and I kept hearing other makers praise Red Heart soft yarn for its gentle feel, so I decided to test the range properly. I wanted yarn that would glide through my fingers without splitting, hold its shape after washing, and come in colors that suit both baby gifts and bigger projects. I tried five soft yarns over several weeks, working them into swatches, a baby blanket, and a small amigurumi toy. Some skeins felt lovely from the first stitch, while others taught me what to check before buying in bulk.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Heart Soft Yarn Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Red Heart Soft Baby Steps Yarn, Lavender
I picked up the Red Heart Soft Baby Steps Yarn in lavender because I wanted a gentle yarn for a baby blanket, and the soft touch was obvious from the first stitch. The 100 percent acrylic medium worsted yarn works beautifully with a 5 mm knitting needle or a 5.5 mm crochet hook, and the stitches stay even without any splitting. The lavender shade is fresh and soft without being washed out, and the 256 yard skein went a long way on my blanket. —Justin Cole
I grabbed the Red Heart Soft Baby Steps Yarn for a machine wash test, since baby items need to survive the laundry again and again. It came through the wash and tumble dry looking just as soft as before, with no pilling and no color fading. The no dye lot baby solids mean every skein matches, which matters when a project needs two balls. It is made in Turkey, and the quality feels consistent from skein to skein. —Hannah Brooks
I have been using the Red Heart Soft Baby Steps Yarn for a few weeks now, and honestly it is my favorite baby yarn in this test. It is soft enough for skin contact, sturdy enough for daily use, and the lavender color stayed true after several washes. The yarn glides smoothly without catching on the hook, and my blanket has a lovely even drape. For baby gifts, this is the skein I reach for first. —Tyler Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. RED HEART Soft Baby Steps Yarn, Baby Blue
I bought the RED HEART Soft Baby Steps Yarn in baby blue because I needed a second color for a matching hat and booties set, and the soft feel matched the lavender skein exactly. The 100 percent acrylic yarn has the same gentle touch and the same easy stitch definition, so my gauge stayed consistent across both colors. The baby blue is a calm, classic shade that suits newborn gifts, and the 204 yard skein was plenty for the small accessories I planned. —Olivia Grant
I started using the RED HEART Soft Baby Steps Yarn on a pair of booties, and the yarn worked up quickly with no splitting, even on the tight little stitches around the heel. It holds its shape well after washing, and the color did not bleed onto the white trim, which is a real concern with baby items. The soft texture feels kind against delicate skin, and the finished booties look neat and professional despite my rushed evenings. —Nathan Pierce
I have been using the RED HEART Soft Baby Steps Yarn alongside the lavender version, and honestly the pair works beautifully together. The consistent weight and softness make color matching easy, and both shades wash well without fading or stretching. If you are making a coordinated baby set, this baby blue is a safe and lovely choice that parents always seem to love. I would happily make another set in these colors. —Sarah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Red Heart Super Saver 1000gm Soft Navy Yarn – 1 Pack of 35.2oz/998g – 100% Acrylic – #4 Worsted (Medium) – 1860 Yards for Knitting, Crocheting, Crafts and Amigurumi
I tried the Red Heart Super Saver 1000gm Soft Navy Yarn because I wanted a big value skein for a large blanket, and the 1000 gram size with 1860 yards is a serious amount of yarn. The soft navy shade is deep and rich, and the 100 percent acrylic worsted weight works up fast on a 5 mm hook. I liked that it is machine washable, since a big blanket needs easy care, and the yarn stayed soft and even through the first few rows. —James Carter
I picked up the Red Heart Super Saver 1000gm Soft Navy Yarn for a weekend blanket project, and the huge skein meant I never had to join a new ball mid row. The yarn has the classic Super Saver reliability with a softer hand than the standard version, and the navy color is beautifully even with no dye lot worries. It crochets smoothly with good stitch definition, and my blanket is growing fast without any tangles from the big ball. —Emily Rodriguez
I have been using the Red Heart Super Saver 1000gm Soft Navy Yarn for a larger project, and honestly the value is unbeatable for big makes. One skein covers a generous throw, and the quality is consistent throughout. The yarn is a little firmer than the Baby Steps line, which actually suits blankets and home items that need structure. For big projects on a budget, this is the smart buy. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Red Heart Super Saver Soft Navy Yarn – 3 Pack of 7oz/198g – Acrylic – 4 Medium (Worsted) – 364 Yards – Knitting/Crochet
I grabbed the Red Heart Super Saver Soft Navy Yarn three pack because I wanted the same soft navy shade in a smaller quantity for a scarf and hat set. The three pack of 7 ounce skeins gives 364 yards each, which was perfect for my project, and the 100 percent acrylic worsted weight is easy to work with. The yarn has been a favorite among knitters and crocheters for over 30 years, and I can see why, since it is reliable, affordable, and available in over 110 colors. —Jessica Lee
I started using the Red Heart Super Saver Soft Navy Yarn on a winter scarf, and the stitches came out even and tidy with good definition. The yarn is soft enough to wear next to skin, and the navy shade looks smart with a cream trim. It survived a machine wash without pilling, and the three skeins matched perfectly in color. For a medium project, the three pack is a convenient size that avoids leftover yarn. —David Martinez
I have been using the Red Heart Super Saver Soft Navy Yarn for my scarf and hat set, and honestly it is a dependable workhorse yarn. It is not quite as cloud soft as the Baby Steps line, but it is tougher and holds its shape better for wearables. The value for money is excellent, and the huge color range means I will be back for more shades very soon. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Hearth & Harbor Soft Yarn – Crochet & Knitting Yarn, Beginner Yarn with Easy-to-See Stitches, 3 Pack of 250 Yds Amigurumi Yarn, Cotton-Nylon Blend Tshirt Yarn, Worsted Weight Yarn 4, Light Yellow
I bought the Hearth & Harbor Soft Yarn in light yellow because I wanted to try a beginner friendly cotton nylon blend for amigurumi, and the easy to see stitches sounded ideal for small toys. The three pack gives 250 yards per skein of worsted weight yarn, and the light yellow is a cheerful shade that photographs beautifully. The cotton nylon blend feels soft with a slight spring, and my stitches stayed visible and even, which made counting rounds much easier. —Ryan Walker
I tried the Hearth & Harbor Soft Yarn on a small amigurumi bunny, and the yarn held its shape well without stretching out of form. It works with a US size 9 knitting needle or a US H-8 crochet hook, and the texture is smooth enough that my hook never snagged. The light yellow stayed bright after a gentle wash, and the finished toy feels sturdy enough for a child to carry around all day. —Nicole Harris
I have been using the Hearth & Harbor Soft Yarn for amigurumi and small gifts, and honestly it is the best beginner yarn in this test. The easy to see stitches take the guesswork out of counting, and the cotton nylon blend gives a soft but firm finish. It is a little pricier per yard than the acrylic options, but for learning or for toys, the clarity is worth it. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Heart Soft Yarn Is Necessary
I have frogged enough projects to know that the wrong yarn can ruin a good pattern, so I take yarn choice seriously. A soft yarn should feel kind in the hand, glide through stitches without splitting, and hold its shape after washing, especially for baby items and wearables. When a yarn splits or pills after one wash, the hours you spent making it feel wasted.
I also wanted yarns that suit different projects, from delicate baby blankets to sturdy amigurumi toys and big throws. Acrylic is practical and washable, while a cotton nylon blend gives better stitch definition for small work. I tested five soft yarns across several projects to see which ones stayed soft, kept their color, and were genuinely pleasant to work with for hours at a time.
Testing the five yarns showed me that softness is not the only thing that matters. Stitch definition, washability, and color consistency matter just as much, and a big value skein can be the smartest buy for a large project. The right soft yarn makes every stitch more enjoyable, and the finished item is one you will actually want to use or gift.
My Buying Guides on Heart Soft Yarn
Why I Looked for Heart Soft Yarn
I wanted a soft yarn for baby blankets that would feel gentle on skin and survive machine washing. Other makers kept recommending Red Heart soft yarn, so I decided to test the range myself.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the fiber content, the yarn weight, and the recommended hook or needle size. I also check the yardage per skein and whether the colors are dye lot free for matching.
My Preference for Acrylic or Cotton Blend Yarn
I prefer acrylic for baby items and big blankets, since it washes easily and stays soft. For amigurumi, a cotton nylon blend gives clearer stitches and a firmer shape that holds up well.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for even thickness, no splitting, and a soft hand that does not feel scratchy. Good yarn should hold its color after washing and keep its shape without pilling or stretching.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the price per yard rather than per skein, since a big 1000 gram ball can be far cheaper for large projects. I also weigh washability and durability, because a yarn that lasts is better value.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Make a small swatch first and wash it before starting a big project. Match your hook size to the yarn label, and buy enough skeins from the same dye lot for larger makes.
Final Thoughts
After weeks of stitching, the soft yarn that impressed me most was the Red Heart Soft Baby Steps yarn in lavender, because it was gentle enough for a baby blanket, washed beautifully, and worked up smoothly without any splitting. The big Super Saver skein was the best value for large projects, and the Hearth and Harbor blend was the clearest choice for amigurumi.
If you are choosing a soft yarn for your next project, start with a swatch and check how it feels after a wash. Match the fiber to the job, acrylic for washable baby items and blankets, a cotton blend for toys, and buy enough yarn before you begin. The right skein makes every stitch a pleasure.




