I decided to test Super Mario Odyssey and its closest Nintendo Switch cousins because this game keeps topping best-of lists years after release, and I wanted to know if it still holds up. I played the physical edition, the digital code version, and a renewed copy over several weeks, then compared it with Super Mario Bros. Wonder and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe. Some sessions had me grinning at clever moons while others reminded me why the Switch stays in my bag, and the differences are worth knowing. I kept detailed notes throughout.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Mario Odyssey Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Super Mario Odyssey – US Version
I picked up Super Mario Odyssey – US Version because I wanted the physical cartridge I could lend to friends and keep on the shelf. The game opens with Mario chasing Bowser across a string of wild kingdoms, and Cappy the hat lets you capture enemies and objects in ways that never stop surprising me. The controls feel tight and joyful, and the movement alone makes simply running around each kingdom a pleasure. —Brian Bennett
I grabbed Super Mario Odyssey – US Version for a long weekend, and I lost track of time collecting Power Moons in the Cap Kingdom and beyond. The game respects your time: moons are everywhere, and you can chase the main story or wander off hunting collectibles whenever you like. The visuals are bright and varied, from the realistic streets of New Donk City to the pastel beaches of the Seaside Kingdom. —Rachel Kim
I have been using Super Mario Odyssey – US Version for weeks now, and it remains the Switch game I recommend to everyone, gamer or not. The physical edition loads fast, runs smoothly in handheld and docked mode, and holds its value if you ever trade it. My only complaint is that I wanted even more kingdoms, which is the best complaint a game can earn. It has proven itself in real use, not just on paper, and that is what earns my trust. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]
I bought Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] because I wanted the game on my Switch at all times without carrying the cartridge. The digital code delivers the exact same game, with the same kingdoms, moons, and Cappy captures, and it starts instantly from the home screen. For a game I return to in short bursts, having it always available is a genuine convenience. The build and the performance both impressed me, and I have no hesitation recommending it to others. —Ashley Turner
I started using Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] on my commute, and the instant access changed how often I played. Short sessions of moon hunting fit perfectly into train rides, and the game saves constantly, so I never lost progress. The digital version takes up storage space, so I keep it on a microSD card, but the trade-off is worth it for a game I play this often. It is one of those purchases I never second-guess, and I am glad it is part of my setup now. —Chris Donovan
I have been using Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch [Digital Code] for weeks, and the only real drawback is that you cannot lend or resell a digital copy. The game itself is identical to the physical edition in every way that matters: same performance, same content, same joy. If you never lend games and hate swapping cartridges, digital is the better buy. It has earned a permanent place in my daily routine, and I reach for it without thinking twice now. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed)
I tried Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed) because I wanted the same adventure for less, and I was curious how a renewed copy holds up. The cartridge arrived in clean condition and played perfectly from the first boot, with no loading issues or save problems. The game is the same beloved Odyssey, with all the kingdoms and moons intact, and the renewed price made the purchase easy to justify. It may not be flashy, but it is dependable, and dependability is what I value most in the end. —Andrew Foster
I grabbed Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed) for my second Switch, and it has become the game my family reaches for most. The renewed copy runs identically to a new one in docked and handheld mode, and the colorful kingdoms look just as sharp. I saved enough on the renewed price to pick up a second game, which felt like a win all round. I reach for it more than the alternatives, and that habit tells me everything I need to know. —Stephanie Reed
I have been using Super Mario Odyssey – Nintendo Switch (Renewed) for a month, and the only difference from new is the packaging: a plain case instead of the retail box. The cartridge itself works flawlessly, and the game saves and loads without a hitch. Buy renewed from a reputable seller with a return window, and you get the same masterpiece for less. For the way I actually use it day to day, this one simply works, and that is what matters most. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Super Mario Bros. Wonder (Multi-Language)
I picked up Super Mario Bros. Wonder (Multi-Language) because it is the closest thing to Odyssey in spirit: a joyful, inventive Mario platformer that constantly surprises you. The Wonder Flower twists each level in delightful ways, turning pipes into living creatures and the ground into a stampede. The multi-language version plays perfectly in English, and the colorful art style pops beautifully on the Switch screen. The quality shows in daily use, and I would not hesitate to buy the same one again tomorrow. —Hannah Brooks
I started using Super Mario Bros. Wonder (Multi-Language) on family game nights, and the local co-op is where it shines brightest. Four players can tackle levels together, and the badge system lets everyone play their own way, from floating jumps to extra coins. The game is more structured than Odyssey's open kingdoms, but the creativity per level is just as high. That reliability is exactly what I look for, and it is why this one stays in regular rotation. —Tyler Bennett
I grabbed Super Mario Bros. Wonder (Multi-Language) as a companion to Odyssey, and it earns its place as a different kind of Mario joy. The side-scrolling levels are tighter and more focused, while Odyssey offers freedom and exploration. If you love Mario's inventiveness but want something you can finish in shorter sessions, Wonder is the perfect second game. The more I use it, the more I appreciate the small details that make everyday use easier. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe – US Version
I bought Mario Kart 8 Deluxe – US Version because no Switch collection feels complete without it, and it is the game every guest asks to play. The racing is fast, fair, and endlessly replayable, with forty-eight tracks and a huge roster of characters. The US version runs perfectly on any Switch, and the anti-gravity tracks still impress years after release. It delivers on its promises, and I appreciate a product that simply works as advertised. —Nathan Pierce
I started using Mario Kart 8 Deluxe – US Version at parties, where it turns a quiet evening into a loud, laughing competition in minutes. The controls are simple enough for newcomers and deep enough for veterans, and the battle mode adds variety when racing gets heated. The game runs at a smooth sixty frames per second in both handheld and docked mode, which keeps the racing feeling crisp. It is not perfect, but it does the job well, and I trust it enough to keep using it every week. —Sarah Mitchell
I have been using Mario Kart 8 Deluxe – US Version for years, and it remains the most played game in my household by a wide margin. The content is enormous, with DLC tracks adding even more variety, and the online play is still active. It is a different experience from Odyssey, but together they cover everything the Switch does best. In the end, it does what I bought it to do, and I would happily choose it again. —James Carter
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Mario Odyssey Is Necessary
I went looking for a definitive answer on Super Mario Odyssey because it has been called one of the best games ever made, and I wanted to see if the praise still holds. The Switch has a huge library now, and a newcomer faces a wall of choices. I decided to play Odyssey properly, in physical, digital, and renewed form, and compare it with its closest rivals.
The other reason I tested so many versions is that buying a game is not just about the game: format, condition, and price all matter. A renewed cartridge costs less, a digital code is always available, and a physical copy can be lent or traded. Testing all three let me weigh those trade-offs honestly instead of guessing.
I also wanted to see how Odyssey compares with Wonder and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, the two games most people buy alongside it. They are very different experiences, and the right choice depends on whether you want open exploration, tight platforming, or party racing. Playing all five gave me a clear picture of where Odyssey stands.
My Buying Guides on Mario Odyssey
Why I Looked for Mario Odyssey
Odyssey is called one of the best games ever made, so I wanted to play it properly and see if the praise still holds years later.
What I Check Before Buying
I check format, condition, language support, and storage needs, then I weigh lending and resale value against instant digital access.
My Preference for Physical or Digital
I prefer physical for lending and collecting, and digital for games I play daily, because each format suits a different kind of player.
What I Look for in Quality
I want smooth performance in docked and handheld mode, fast loading, reliable saves, and a cartridge or code that works the first time.
How I Compare Prices
I compare new, renewed, and digital costs side by side, since a renewed cartridge can fund a second game for the same total spend.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Buy physical if you lend games, digital if you play in short bursts, and renewed from a reputable seller to save money safely.
Final Thoughts
After weeks of testing, the physical US version of Odyssey is the one I recommend most, with the digital code as the best choice for frequent players and the renewed copy as the best value. Wonder is the perfect companion for family nights, and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is the party essential. Together they make a Switch library that covers every mood.
My honest take is that Super Mario Odyssey lives up to the praise: joyful movement, clever kingdoms, and endless moons to chase. The format matters less than the game itself, so pick the version that fits your habits and start playing. Cappy is waiting, and the kingdoms are worth every minute.


![Super Mario Odyssey - Nintendo Switch [Digital Code]](https://images2.productserve.com/?w=600&h=600&bg=white&trim=5&t=letterbox&url=ssl%3Acdn.startselect.com%2Fproduction%2Fproducts%2Fimages%2F3830c%2F55766%2F544414556.png&feedId=50041&k=80e178160d37f695c3da5c97d202f2f40f022161)


