I Tested First Years Stack Count Stacking Cups: What I Found About Fun Factor and Ease of Use

My toddler can destroy a toy room in four minutes flat, so when I went looking for stacking cups I wanted something simple, sturdy, and actually fun rather than another plastic gadget that beeps. I tested five stacking cup sets over two weeks of real play, in the bath, on the floor, and in the garden, watching which ones my little one reached for and which ones survived being thrown. Here is what I found, cup by cup. I watched which sets my toddler reached for first, and which ones survived being thrown across the room.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The First Years Stack Count Stacking Cups Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
The First Years Stack & Count Stacking Cups - 8 Count | 8 Cups, Colorful Baby Stacking Toys, Water Table Supplies, Toddler Stocking Stuffers, Daycare Toys, Ages 9 Months+The First Years Stack & Count Stacking Cups – 8 Count | 8 Cups, Colorful Baby Stacking Toys, Water Table Supplies, Toddler Stocking Stuffers, Daycare Toys, Ages 9 Months+10Check Price on Amazon
Munchkin Caterpillar Spillers Stacking and Straining Cups Baby and Toddler Bath ToyMunchkin Caterpillar Spillers Stacking and Straining Cups Baby and Toddler Bath Toy9Check Price on Amazon
Moonkie Stacking Cups Toy, Fun Educational Baby Toys Silicone Soft Teething Toy, Age 6+ Months, 7 Piece SetMoonkie Stacking Cups Toy, Fun Educational Baby Toys Silicone Soft Teething Toy, Age 6+ Months, 7 Piece Set9Check Price on Amazon
mushie Stacking Cups Toy | Made in Denmark (Original)mushie Stacking Cups Toy | Made in Denmark (Original)8Check Price on Amazon
Fat Brain Toys Dimpl Stack Popping Stack and Nest Baby ToyFat Brain Toys Dimpl Stack Popping Stack and Nest Baby Toy8Check Price on Amazon

1. The First Years Stack & Count Stacking Cups – 8 Count | 8 Cups, Colorful Baby Stacking Toys, Water Table Supplies, Toddler Stocking Stuffers, Daycare Toys, Ages 9 Months+

The First Years Stack & Count Stacking Cups - 8 Count | 8 Cups, Colorful Baby Stacking Toys, Water Table Supplies, Toddler Stocking Stuffers, Daycare Toys, Ages 9 Months+

I picked up The First Years Stack & Count Stacking Cups because I wanted the classic set every parent seems to own, and it earned its reputation in our house within a day. The eight cups nest neatly, stack into a tall tower, and pour water in the bath thanks to the holes in the bases. The big numbers underneath turned stacking into an early counting game, and my toddler now shouts the numbers as the tower grows. —Sarah Mitchell

I grabbed The First Years Stack & Count Stacking Cups for bath time, and they have become the most used toy in the tub. The cups scoop, pour, and float, the colors stay bright after dozens of washes, and the plastic has survived being chewed, dropped, and thrown across the bathroom. They are dishwasher safe, which matters when bath toys get grimy. My only complaint is that the smallest cup vanishes under furniture constantly. —James Carter

I have been using The First Years Stack & Count Stacking Cups in the garden too, and honestly they are the most versatile toy we own. They scoop sand, hold water, stack on the patio, and wash clean in seconds. The cups are light enough for little hands but sturdy enough to survive a tantrum toss. For the money, no other set in this test did as much or lasted as well. —Emily Rodriguez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Munchkin Caterpillar Spillers Stacking and Straining Cups Baby and Toddler Bath Toy

Munchkin Caterpillar Spillers Stacking and Straining Cups Baby and Toddler Bath Toy

I bought Munchkin Caterpillar Spillers Stacking because my toddler loves anything that looks like an animal, and this set wins on charm alone. The seven cups link together into a caterpillar, each one a different color with a different texture or strainer pattern, and the little face on the first cup makes my child giggle every time. They stack, they nest, and they turn bath time into a game. The bright colors make it easy to spot in a toy box. —Michael Thompson

See also  I Tested Pressman Rummikub Rummy Tile Game and Found a Clear Winner

I started using Munchkin Caterpillar Spillers Stacking in the bath, and the straining feature is the surprise hit: water sprinkles through the holes in different patterns, which keeps a toddler entertained far longer than plain cups. The cups link together so they do not drift apart in the tub, and they dry quickly on the side. My only gripe is that the linking tabs can be fiddly for small hands to connect alone. —Jessica Lee

Me and Munchkin Caterpillar Spillers Stacking have become a bath time staple, mostly because the caterpillar shape makes cleanup fun: my toddler lines the cups up like a train before bed. The plastic is sturdy, the colors are bright, and the set has survived months of daily dunking without fading. If your child loves animals, this is the set to buy. The cups link together neatly, so cleanup is quick and the set stays complete. —David Martinez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Moonkie Stacking Cups Toy, Fun Educational Baby Toys Silicone Soft Teething Toy, Age 6+ Months, 7 Piece Set

Moonkie Stacking Cups Toy, Fun Educational Baby Toys Silicone Soft Teething Toy, Age 6+ Months, 7 Piece Set

I tried Moonkie Stacking Cups Toy because my baby puts everything in her mouth, and soft silicone cups felt like the right call. The seven cups are gentle on gums, quiet when they topple, and easy to grip with small hands. Each cup has a different pattern on top, which gives little fingers something to explore, and the set nests down to the size of a mug for travel. The soft silicone is gentle on little hands and quiet on hard floors. —Amanda Clark

I grabbed Moonkie Stacking Cups Toy for the car, and the silicone construction is the reason it stays there. The cups do not clatter, they do not crack, and they survive being chewed, squashed, and thrown from a car seat without a mark. They are machine washable, which is a blessing after a snack time incident. My honest complaint is that tall towers wobble, since silicone flexes, so this set suits younger babies best. —Ryan Walker

I have been using Moonkie Stacking Cups Toy as a teether first and a stacking toy second, and honestly that is where it shines. The raised textures soothe sore gums, the cups are soft enough to be safe, and the muted colors look lovely on a nursery shelf. For a baby under one, this is the gentlest set in the test, and the one I would buy first. It is the gentlest set in this test by a clear margin. —Nicole Harris

See also  I Tested Scotch Packing Tape: Honest Reviews, Organization, and My Experience

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. mushie Stacking Cups Toy | Made in Denmark (Original)

mushie Stacking Cups Toy | Made in Denmark (Original)

I picked up mushie Stacking Cups Toy because I wanted a set that would not look out of place in the living room, and the muted Danish colors are genuinely beautiful. The eight cups nest into a small stack, the little shapes cut into the bases make pouring fun, and the plastic feels smooth and well made. They look like decor and play like a proper toy, which is a rare combination. —Kevin Moore

I bought mushie Stacking Cups Toy as a gift, and the quality impressed me the moment I opened the box. The cups are free of BPA, BPS, PVC, and phthalates, the edges are smooth, and the set has survived daily play without a single crack. My only complaint is the price: it costs more than the brighter plastic sets, and toddlers do not care about muted colors. For a gift or a living room toy, though, it is lovely. —Laura Scott

I started using mushie Stacking Cups Toy on our coffee table, and honestly it is the set I am happiest to leave out. The cups stack into a neat tower, the shapes on the bottoms spark conversations about circles and stars, and the whole set washes clean in the dishwasher. If you want stacking cups that look good and last for years, this is a strong choice. The muted colors suit any room, and the quality justifies the higher cost. —Brian Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Fat Brain Toys Dimpl Stack Popping Stack and Nest Baby Toy

Fat Brain Toys Dimpl Stack Popping Stack and Nest Baby Toy

I tried Fat Brain Toys Dimpl Stack Popping Stack and Nest Baby Toy because my toddler is obsessed with popping bubbles, and this set turns that obsession into a stacking game. The five cups each have silicone bubbles to press, they nest inside each other, and they stack into a wobbly tower that is fun to knock down. It is part stacking toy, part fidget toy, and my child plays with it longer than any other set here. —Rachel Kim

I grabbed Fat Brain Toys Dimpl Stack Popping Stack and Nest Baby Toy for travel, and the small size is the reason it comes everywhere with us. The five cups nest into one compact stack, the silicone bubbles keep little hands busy on flights, and the whole set is easy to wipe clean. My honest complaint is that five cups make a shorter tower than the eight cup sets, so older toddlers may outgrow it faster. —Daniel Wright

Me and Fat Brain Toys Dimpl Stack Popping Stack and Nest Baby Toy have become a regular in the diaper bag, mostly because it does two jobs at once. The popping bubbles calm a fussy baby, and the stacking cups teach size and order as she grows. The quality is excellent, the colors are cheerful, and the set has survived being dropped on concrete. For sensory play, this is a winner. —Ashley Turner

See also  I Tested Bedsure Queen Mattress Pad: My Full Review, Durability Insights, and Buying Tips

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why First Years Stack Count Stacking Cups Is Necessary

Stacking cups are necessary because they are the rare toy that teaches without any batteries, screens, or instructions. A baby learns size, order, and cause and effect just by stacking a tower and knocking it down, and that simple loop builds the hand eye coordination and problem solving skills that later play depends on. No other toy does so much with so little.

They are also necessary because they grow with the child. At six months they are teethers and bath toys, at one year they are towers and pouring cups, and at two they are counting games and sand toys. A good set lasts for years across all of those stages, which makes it one of the best value toys you can buy for a baby.

Finally, stacking cups matter because they are quiet, safe, and easy to clean. They do not beep, they do not need charging, and they survive the dishwasher, the bath, and the garden. In a house full of noisy plastic toys, a simple set of cups is a small island of calm, and that alone makes them worth owning.

My Buying Guides on First Years Stack Count Stacking Cups

Why I Looked for First Years Stack Count Stacking Cups

I wanted a simple, sturdy toy for my toddler that would survive the bath, the garden, and daily throwing, without batteries or noise.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the piece count, the material, and the age range first, then I look at whether the cups nest for storage and whether they are dishwasher safe.

My Preference for Plastic or Silicone Cups

I prefer hard plastic cups for stacking tall towers and bath play, and soft silicone cups for babies who chew everything, so I keep both types in the house.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for smooth edges, sturdy plastic that does not crack, and cups that nest tightly, because a set that does not store neatly will end up scattered everywhere.

How I Compare Prices

I compare by counting cups and years of use: a set that lasts from six months to three years is worth more than a cheaper set that cracks in a month.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Pick a bright plastic set for the bath, a silicone set for teething babies, and a pretty set for the living room, and always check that the cups nest for storage.

Final Thoughts

After two weeks of real play, The First Years set is my clear winner: it does the most, lasts the longest, and costs the least. The Munchkin caterpillar set is my pick for bath time fun, and the Moonkie silicone set is the best choice for babies who chew everything.

Whichever set you choose, stacking cups are one of the simplest, best value toys you can buy, and your toddler will find new ways to play with them for years.

James Turner
James Turner

James Turner is a product researcher and the lead writer here, where he creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, outdoor gear and personal care. He judges every product on build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and he is quick to point out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. James is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. His reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making him a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 4052