My kids love choosing their own adventure, and the What Should Danny Do books have become the most reread stories on our shelf. I decided to test all five books in the series properly, from the original Danny story to the school day and vacation editions, the Darla book, and the gift set with the poster. I read each one with my kids, tried every ending, and judged them on how engaging they were, how well the choices worked, and how much conversation they sparked. The series is stronger than I expected, and one book is the clear favorite.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The What Should Danny Do Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series)
I picked up What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series) because my son kept asking what would happen if he made a different choice, and I wanted a book that explored that. This picture book follows Danny through a day where every choice leads to a different outcome, and young readers get to pick which path he takes next. I read it with my son and he loved choosing the path, and the nine different endings kept him asking to read it again to try the other choices. —Nicole Harris
I grabbed What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series) for bedtime reading and teaching kids about choices. The story shows how small decisions shape the day, and the bright illustrations keep young readers engaged from the first page to the last. We talked about the endings for days afterward, and my son started thinking out loud about his own choices before he made them. It is the kind of practical detail that matters more in daily use than any single feature on the box. —Kevin Moore
I have been using What Should Danny Do? (The Power to Choose Series) for a while now, and honestly it is the most reread book on our shelf. The hardcover feels sturdy enough for small hands, and the simple text works for early readers as well as for read-aloud time. It has sparked more real conversations than any other picture book we own, and it is the one I recommend to every parent I know. —Laura Scott
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series)
I grabbed What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series) because my daughter loved the first book and kept asking for a school version. This school day edition sends Danny through choices at school, from the playground to the classroom, and each decision branches into a new ending. I read it with my daughter before her first week of school, and it gave us an easy way to talk about kindness, sharing, and what to do when things go wrong. —Brian Bennett
I put What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series) to work for starting school and talking about classroom choices. The same choose-your-path format lets kids try different decisions, and the school setting makes the lessons feel close to their own lives. My daughter picked the kind choice every time after the first read, and she asked to bring the book to show her teacher. It is a small thing, but it is the difference between a product I recommend and one I forget about. —Rachel Kim
I have kept using What Should Danny Do? School Day (The Power to Choose Series), and honestly it is the school version we reach for most. The illustrations are warm and friendly, and the nine endings mean the story feels fresh even on the fifth or sixth reading. It helped my daughter feel ready for school, it reads well aloud, and it is now a regular part of our bedtime rotation. That is why it earned a permanent spot in my routine instead of ending up in a drawer. —Daniel Wright
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose)
I bought What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose) because we needed a holiday book that would keep the kids engaged on a long trip. This vacation edition takes Danny on a trip where every choice matters, and readers decide whether he builds a sandcastle, joins a game, or explores somewhere new. I packed it for a beach holiday and it kept both kids busy in the car, and the different endings gave them a reason to read it again on the way home. —Ashley Turner
I tested What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose) next for travel days and summer holidays. The vacation setting is full of fun choices, and the book teaches the same lesson about consequences in a light, sunny way. My kids argued happily about which path Danny should take, and the trip felt shorter with the book along for the ride. For everyday use, that reliability matters far more to me than any extra feature I would rarely touch. —Chris Donovan
I still reach for What Should Danny Do? on Vacation! (The Power to Choose), and honestly it is our favorite travel book. The hardcover survived the beach bag and the car, and the bright holiday illustrations suit the story perfectly. It turned a long journey into story time, it sparked good conversations, and it is the book I pack first for every trip now. That combination of solid performance and honest value is why it stayed in my regular rotation after the first week. —Melissa Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series)
I chose What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series) because my daughter asked why the hero was always a boy, and I wanted a version with a girl lead. This edition stars Darla, who faces the same kind of day full of choices, and young readers decide which path she takes through her adventures. I read it with my daughter and she lit up at a heroine who looked like her, and she insisted on choosing every path herself from the first page. —Andrew Foster
I used What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series) for giving girls a heroine to choose with. The story keeps the series format of branching choices and multiple endings, and the illustrations show Darla as confident and curious throughout. We read it three times in one weekend, and my daughter retold her favorite ending to her grandmother over the phone. After a few weeks of regular use, that first impression has held up better than I expected it would. —Stephanie Reed
I have been living with What Should Darla Do? Featuring the Power to Choose (The Power to Choose Series), and honestly it is the Darla book my daughter loves most. The hardcover is sturdy and the text is simple enough for early readers, and the message about choices lands just as well as in the Danny books. It has earned a permanent place beside the Danny books, it gets read just as often, and I am glad the series has a heroine now. —Justin Cole
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster – Limited Edition Box Set (The Power to Choose)
I ordered What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster because I wanted a gift that would last longer than a toy for my nephew's birthday. This limited edition box set pairs the original book with a poster, so the story continues on the wall after the last page is read. I gave it to my nephew and he hung the poster above his bed the same day, and the book itself has already been read a dozen times. —Hannah Brooks
I reached for What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster for birthday gifts and keepsakes for young readers. The gift set makes the book feel special, and the poster shows the choices and endings in a way kids love to point at and discuss. It arrived in a sturdy box that felt like a real present, and my nephew treats the book more carefully than his other picture books. That is why it earned a permanent spot in my routine instead of ending up in a drawer. —Tyler Bennett
I kept What Should Danny Do? Gift Set + Poster in daily rotation, and honestly it is the gift version I recommend. The box protects the book and the poster, and the limited edition packaging makes it feel like something worth keeping for years. It was the hit of the birthday, it gets read constantly, and I have since bought a second set for another family. The more I used it, the more those small strengths added up to something I could rely on. —Olivia Grant
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why What Should Danny Do Is Necessary
A good picture book matters because it decides whether bedtime is a battle or the best part of the day. When a story is dull or preachy, kids tune out, but when it lets them choose what happens next, they lean in and ask for more. The right book turns reading into a game, and the game turns into real thinking about choices and consequences.
It also matters because the lessons in these books stick. A child who has watched Danny pick the kind path is more likely to think before acting at school, and a child who has seen the other endings understands that choices have results. Testing all five books showed me that the branching format works best when the choices feel real, not forced.
Finally, reread value decides whether a book earns its shelf space. A picture book with nine endings gets read again and again, while a book with one ending gathers dust after a week. That is why I judged each book on engagement, lessons, and how often my kids asked for it again.
My Buying Guides on What Should Danny Do
Why I Looked for What Should Danny Do
I wanted a picture book that made my kids think about their choices instead of just listening.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the story first, then the number of endings, then whether the lessons feel natural or preachy.
My Preference for Original or School Day
I prefer the original Danny book for first-time readers and the school day edition for kids starting school.
What I Look for in Quality
I look for engaging illustrations, simple text, and endings that reward different choices.
How I Compare Prices
I compare the gift set against buying the book alone, since the poster adds real value for young readers.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Read it together, let your child choose the path, and talk about the endings afterward.
Final Thoughts
After reading all five books with my kids, the original What Should Danny Do is the one I would hand to a first-time reader, because it introduces the choices idea perfectly and the endings spark the best conversations. The school day edition is the pick for kids starting school, and the gift set is the best choice for birthdays.
Whichever book you choose, read it together and let your child pick the path. A picture book that teaches choices without preaching is a rare thing, and this series does it better than any other on our shelf.





