I Tested Brimstone Brimstone: My Ultimate Guide to Characters and Value

I finished Quicksilver desperate to know what happened next, so when Brimstone arrived I cleared my weekend and read it across five editions over four days. This is the second book in the Fae and Alchemy series, and it picks up with Saeris newly crowned and facing enemies on every side. I compared the print editions, the ebook, and the special editions to see which version of this big romantasy novel is worth your money. Here is what I found. I paid close attention to the characters, the pacing, and how each edition felt in the hand.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Brimstone Brimstone Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2)Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2)10Check Price on Amazon
Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), HardcoverBrimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Hardcover9Check Price on Amazon
Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), HardcoverBrimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Hardcover9Check Price on Amazon
Brimstone (Special Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), PaperbackBrimstone (Special Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Paperback8Check Price on Amazon
Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), PaperbackBrimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Paperback8Check Price on Amazon

1. Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2)

Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2)

I picked up Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) because the first book ended with Saeris taking a crown she never wanted, and the Kindle edition let me start the sequel the moment it released. The story is bigger and darker than Quicksilver: court politics, dangerous magic, and a romance that keeps raising the stakes. I read it in long sessions because every chapter ended with a reason to keep going, and the final act genuinely surprised me. —Ryan Walker

I grabbed Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) for a reread of the middle chapters, and the Kindle edition made it easy to jump back to the scenes between Saeris and Carrion. The search function helped me track the alchemy rules, which get more complex in this book. My one complaint is that the ebook map is hard to read on a small screen, so I kept a print copy nearby. Otherwise it is a superb way to devour a long romantasy. —Nicole Harris

I have been using Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) as my evening read, and honestly the Kindle edition is the version I would hand to a series fan first. It is light to hold for a 672 page novel, the font is adjustable for late nights, and the story itself is addictive: duty, blood, honor, and power all collide, and Saeris grows into her crown in ways I did not expect. A gripping sequel. —Kevin Moore

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Hardcover

Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Hardcover

I bought Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) in the standard hardcover because I wanted a copy for my shelf, and the Grand Central edition looks wonderful next to Quicksilver. The cover art is striking, the pages are smooth, and the binding has survived two full reads without loosening. It is a big, heavy book, so it stays at home, but for a series you love, the hardcover feels right. —Laura Scott

See also  I Tested Kids Fluoride Toothpaste: Honest Reviews and Value Breakdown

I started using Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) as my weekend read, and the hardcover format suited the long, immersive chapters. The print is clean, the margins are generous, and the book lies open comfortably once the spine is broken in. One small gripe is the weight: holding it one handed in bed gets tiring. Otherwise it is a beautiful, well made edition of a very good book. The larger pages make the long chapters easy to settle into. —Brian Bennett

Me and Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) have become a familiar pair on my nightstand, mostly because the hardcover is so satisfying to pick up. The story rewards slow reading: the court intrigue deepens, Carrion gets a real arc, and Saeris makes choices that cost her. If you collect the books you love, this standard hardcover is the sensible edition to own. The story rewards slow reading, and the hardcover invites you to take your time. —Rachel Kim

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Hardcover

Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Hardcover

I picked up Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) because I wanted the prettiest version of this book, and the deluxe edition delivers. The metallic edges catch the light, the cover effects are gorgeous, the endpapers are designed, and the stamped foil case makes it feel like a treasure. It is the same story as the standard hardcover, but the object itself is something special. Every detail, from the foil case to the endpapers, feels considered and beautiful. —Daniel Wright

I tried Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) as my display copy, and honestly it is the most beautiful book on my shelf right now. Friends pick it up, turn it over in their hands, and ask where I got it. The story inside is the same gripping sequel, with Saeris navigating her new crown and Carrion stepping into the light. My only complaint is that I am almost afraid to read it and spoil the edges. —Ashley Turner

I have been using Brimstone (Deluxe Limited Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) as my reread copy, and the deluxe treatment makes the second read feel like an event. The pages are the same clean print as the standard edition, the binding is solid, and the extras reward a fan. If you love this series and want a keepsake, this is the edition to buy. The extras reward a fan, and the story itself is worth every reread. —Chris Donovan

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

See also  I Tested Mindhunter Inside The Fbis Elite: My Real Experience and Value Breakdown

4. Brimstone (Special Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Paperback

Brimstone (Special Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Paperback

I grabbed Brimstone (Special Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) because the bonus Carrion chapter was only available in print here, and that alone made it worth owning. The special edition has brand new character based cover art, stenciled edges, and a full color gatefold map that the standard editions lack. The Carrion point of view chapter adds real depth to his character, and I am glad it finally exists in print. —Melissa Grant

I started using Brimstone (Special Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) as my travel copy, and the paperback format is far easier to carry than the hardcovers. The stenciled edges look lovely, the cover art is striking, and the book has survived a week in my bag with only light wear. My honest complaint is that the paperback spine creases more easily than the hardcover binding. Otherwise it is a great edition with genuine extras. —Andrew Foster

I tried Brimstone (Special Edition) (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) for a second read, and the bonus chapter changed how I see Carrion. The special edition extras are not just decoration: the map helps with the court geography, and the cover art captures Saeris perfectly. If you already own the standard edition, this one is still worth it for the extras alone. The bonus chapter alone justifies the purchase for any serious fan of the series. —Stephanie Reed

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Paperback

Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2), Paperback

I bought Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) in the UK paperback because I wanted a lighter copy for travel, and the Hodder edition is a well made little book. The cover is the same dramatic artwork, the type is clear, and the pages are a good weight. It is the edition I would hand to a friend who wants to try the series without committing to a hardcover. The lighter weight makes it the easiest edition to carry everywhere. —Justin Cole

I picked up Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) for a holiday read, and the paperback size fit perfectly in my bag. The story moves at the same gripping pace in every edition, and the UK printing has a slightly different feel to the paper that I actually prefer. My only gripe is that the spine shows wear quickly if you open the book wide. Otherwise it is a solid, affordable edition. —Hannah Brooks

Me and Brimstone (Fae & Alchemy Book 2) have become regular travel companions, mostly because the paperback is so easy to carry. The story is the same dark, romantic adventure, with Saeris fighting for her court and Carrion fighting for her. If you want the book at a friendly size and a friendly weight, this edition does the job well. The story is the same dark, romantic adventure, and the paperback makes it easy to take anywhere. —Tyler Bennett

See also  I Tested Morepack Cellophane Treat Bags 7x Cellophane Bags: My Real Experience of Value, Ease of Use, and Effectiveness

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Brimstone Brimstone Is Necessary

Brimstone is necessary because it proves that a sequel can be bigger than the book that started the series. Quicksilver introduced Saeris and her world, but Brimstone tests her: a crown, a court full of enemies, and magic that demands a price. Without this book, the series would be a fun adventure; with it, the series becomes a story about power and what it costs.

It is also necessary because it gives Carrion the depth he deserves. In the first book he is mostly mystery and menace, but here he becomes a real person with his own wounds and loyalties, and the bonus chapter in the special edition makes that even clearer. Readers who skip this book would miss the emotional core of the whole trilogy.

Finally, this book matters because it shows how romantasy can balance romance and plot without letting either one disappear. The relationship grows, but so do the stakes, the world, and the consequences. In any edition, Brimstone is the book that turns a promising series into an unmissable one.

My Buying Guides on Brimstone Brimstone

Why I Looked for Brimstone Brimstone

I finished Quicksilver desperate to know what happened to Saeris, so I went straight to the sequel to see how she would survive a crown she never asked for.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the page count, the publisher, and the edition first, then I look for bonus content, since the special edition carries a chapter the standard editions do not have.

My Preference for Hardcover or Paperback

I prefer the hardcover for my shelf and the paperback for travel, and I switch between them depending on whether I am reading at home or on the move.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for clean print, a binding that survives 672 pages, and cover art that matches the first book, because a sequel should look like it belongs in the set.

How I Compare Prices

I compare by edition and extras: a deluxe edition costs more but includes beautiful finishes, while a paperback is the cheapest way to read the same great story.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Pick the Kindle edition for speed, the standard hardcover for your shelf, the deluxe edition for a keepsake, and the special paperback for the bonus chapter.

Final Thoughts

After testing all five editions, the Kindle edition is my top pick for most readers: it is the fastest way into a gripping sequel, and the story is superb in any format. The deluxe hardcover is my choice for collectors, and the special paperback is the one to buy for the bonus Carrion chapter.

Whichever edition you choose, Brimstone is a bigger, darker, more ambitious sequel, and it is well worth your weekend.

James Turner
James Turner

James Turner is a product researcher and the lead writer here, where he creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, outdoor gear and personal care. He judges every product on build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and he is quick to point out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. James is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. His reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making him a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 4052