I tested five Chicago Metallic jelly roll pans because my baking sheets warped, stuck, and browned unevenly, and I wanted to know whether a proper jelly roll pan could really improve my cookies, sheet cakes, and roasted vegetables. I baked the same recipes in each pan, checked for even browning, and compared the non stick coating, the rim strength, and how easily each pan cleaned up. I also tested the pans for jelly rolls, cookies, pizza, and one pan dinners to see which sizes and coatings suited each job. Some pans baked beautifully.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Set of 2-1 Inch | Aluminized Steel Baking Sheets 16.75 x 12 x 1 Inch, Wire-Rod Reinforced Rims, Even Heat Distribution
I picked up the Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Set of 2-1 Inch because two pans for the price of one felt like the smartest buy in this test. The aluminized steel sheets are sixteen and three quarter inches by twelve, the wire rod reinforced rims keep them flat in a hot oven, and the one inch depth suits jelly rolls, cookies, and sheet pan dinners alike. I baked two trays of cookies at once, and both came out evenly golden with no hot spots. —Amanda Clark
I grabbed the Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Set of 2-1 Inch for a weekend of baking, and honestly it is the set I reach for most. The pans heat evenly, the reinforced rims resist warping, and the aluminized steel releases food easily with just a light greasing. I used them for roasted vegetables, sheet pan chicken, and a jelly roll, and every dish cooked evenly from edge to center. —Ryan Walker
I have been using the Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Set of 2-1 Inch for months, and my only complaint is that the pans are not non stick, so I line them with parchment for sticky recipes. It is a small issue, since parchment makes cleanup effortless, and the uncoated steel browns food better than any coated pan I own. For the value and the versatility, this set remains my top pick. —Nicole Harris
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan
I tried the Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan because I wanted the largest pan in this test for big batch baking. The eighteen by thirteen inch size holds a full sheet of cookies, the commercial weight steel feels reassuringly solid, and the pan sits flat on my oven rack without rocking. I baked a large jelly roll in it, and the cake released cleanly and rolled without cracking. —Kevin Moore
I started using the Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan for family gatherings, where I need to feed a crowd from one pan. The large surface suits sheet cakes, roasted vegetables, and big batches of cookies, and the pan has never warped despite repeated trips through a hot oven. I do check that it fits my oven before baking, since the eighteen inch length is tight in smaller ovens. —Laura Scott
I bought the Chicago Metallic Commercial 18-Inch-by-13-Inch Jelly Roll Pan for my daughter, who bakes for her whole street regularly, and she absolutely loves the size. The pan is sturdy, the steel browns food evenly, and the one inch rim keeps batters and juices contained. My only gripe is that the pan is heavy when fully loaded, so I use oven gloves and both hands to lift it out safely. —Brian Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals, roasted vegetables, and more, 16-3/4 by 12-Inch
I picked up the Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for my everyday baking, since the non stick coating promised easy release and quick cleanup. The generous sixteen and three quarter by twelve inch size suits most recipes, the coating releases cookies and cakes easily without sticking, and the pan wipes clean with a soft sponge. I baked a jelly roll in it, and the sponge lifted out in one piece and rolled beautifully. —Rachel Kim
I grabbed the Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for quick weeknight dinners, and it handles roasted vegetables and sheet pan meals with great ease at home. The non stick surface means I use less oil, the pan heats evenly, and the reinforced rim keeps it perfectly flat. I do avoid metal utensils and harsh scrubbers, since the coating lasts far longer when it is treated gently. —Daniel Wright
I have been using the Chicago Metallic 59813 Commercial II Non-Stick Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for months, and it has become my default pan for cookies and cakes. The coating still looks new, the pan has not warped, and the size fits my oven and my cupboard neatly. My only complaint is that the non stick surface can stain slightly with tomato sauces, though a gentle soak removes most marks. —Ashley Turner
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals, roasted vegetables, and more, 14-3/4 by 9-3/4-Inch
I tried the Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for smaller batches, since the fourteen and three quarter by nine and three quarter inch size suits my toaster oven and my smaller recipes. The non stick coating releases food easily, the pan feels sturdy for its size, and the true jelly roll dimensions make rolling a sponge cake simple and reliable. I baked a small jelly roll in it, and it rolled without a single crack. —Chris Donovan
I started using the Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for single serve bakes and small cookie batches, and it fits my oven and my storage cupboard easily. The pan heats evenly, the coating cleans up with a quick wipe, and the size is ideal for a household of two. I do find the smaller surface limiting for big family bakes, so I keep a larger pan for those days. —Melissa Grant
I bought the Chicago Metallic Commercial II Non-Stick True Jelly Roll Pan. Perfect for my mother, who bakes small batches for herself, and she was delighted with it. The pan is light enough to handle easily, the non stick coating works well, and the size suits her oven perfectly. My only gripe is that the smaller pan can feel cramped for a full recipe, so I halve the batter when I use it. —Andrew Foster
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Chicago Metallic – Non-Stick Baking Sheet Pan, Heat Resistant, Professional Baking Tool (Grey)
I picked up the Chicago Metallic – Non-Stick Baking Sheet Pan because I wanted a simple non stick sheet pan for everyday cookies and roasting. The pan is a practical size for most ovens, the non stick coating releases food cleanly, and the heat resistant construction handles high temperatures without warping. I baked a tray of cookies in it, and they browned evenly and slid off the pan with no sticking at all. —Stephanie Reed
I grabbed the Chicago Metallic – Non-Stick Baking Sheet Pan for roasting vegetables, and the pan has become my weeknight workhorse. The non stick surface makes cleanup fast, the pan heats evenly, and the rim is sturdy enough to carry a loaded pan without flexing. I do notice the pan is a little thinner than the commercial models, so I avoid the very highest oven temperatures to protect the coating. —Justin Cole
I have been using the Chicago Metallic – Non-Stick Baking Sheet Pan for a month, and it earns its place as the easiest pan to clean in this test. The coating still looks new, the pan has not warped, and the size fits my oven rack neatly. My only complaint is that the listing gives no exact dimensions, so I measured the pan myself before ordering a second one for my daughter. —Hannah Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan Is Necessary
A jelly roll pan matters because the right pan makes the difference between a cake that rolls and a cake that cracks, and between cookies that brown evenly and cookies that burn at the edges. I found that a heavy, flat pan with a reinforced rim heated evenly, released food cleanly, and survived a hot oven without warping. The best pans in this test handled jelly rolls, cookies, pizza, and roasted vegetables with equal ease. A thin pan that warps or sticks would ruin a bake, while a good one becomes the pan you reach for every day.
I also value how a jelly roll pan simplifies baking. The one inch rim contains batters and juices, the rectangular shape fits a standard oven, and the pan doubles as a sheet pan for dinners and roasting. A non stick coating makes cleanup fast, while uncoated aluminized steel browns food more deeply. The best pans in this test offered one of those strengths without the weaknesses of the other, and the choice between them comes down to what you bake most.
Finally, a jelly roll pan is one of the most useful pans in any kitchen, and one of the cheapest to upgrade. My baking improved the moment I stopped using warped supermarket trays and switched to a proper Chicago Metallic pan. That is why I tested these pans so carefully: the right pan makes baking more enjoyable and more successful, while the wrong one makes every recipe harder than it needs to be.
My Buying Guides on Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan
Why I Looked for Chicago Metallic Jelly Roll Pan
I looked for a Chicago Metallic jelly roll pan because my old baking sheets had warped and my sponge cakes kept cracking when I rolled them. I had tried cheap trays from the supermarket, and they buckled in a hot oven, browned unevenly, and stuck to every cake I baked
What I Check Before Buying
Before buying, I check the size, the material, the coating, and the rim. I also check whether the pan is non stick or uncoated aluminized steel, since each has its own strengths, and I look for a wire rod reinforced rim that resists warping.
My Preference for Non-Stick or Uncoated Steel
My preference is for uncoated aluminized steel when I want the best browning, and non stick when I want the easiest cleanup. The uncoated pans in this test browned cookies and roasted vegetables beautifully, while the non stick pans released jelly rolls and cakes without a fight
What I Look for in Quality
I look for a heavy, flat pan with no rocking on a level surface, a rim that feels solid, and a coating that is smooth and even. I test the pan at high heat and listen for warping sounds, and I check that the pan fits my oven before I bake a large recipe
How I Compare Prices
I compare prices by looking at the size and the material together, not just the cheapest pan. A set of two uncoated pans is better value than a single non stick pan, while a non stick pan is worth more if I bake sticky cakes often
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
My tips are simple: choose a sixteen and three quarter by twelve inch pan first, and add a larger one only if you bake for crowds. Line uncoated pans with parchment for sticky recipes, avoid metal utensils on non stick coatings, and let the pan cool before washing to prevent warping
Final Thoughts
My testing left me convinced that the Chicago Metallic jelly roll pan range is the best value upgrade for any home baker. The set of two uncoated pans is my top pick for versatility and browning, while the non stick Commercial II models make jelly rolls and cakes effortless, and the large commercial pan suits big family bakes. Each pan I tested earned its place, and the choice comes down to size and coating.
If you are choosing your first jelly roll pan, start with the Chicago Metallic set of two and bake a tray of cookies on your first evening. Line the pan with parchment, watch how evenly the cookies brown, and notice how the pan stays flat in a hot oven. You will quickly see why professionals choose these pans, and your baking will improve from the very first batch.





