I Tested Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size: Honest Reviews, Design, and My Verdict

I wanted a game night option that anyone could learn in a minute, so I spent several evenings testing penny drop boxes with family and friends of all ages. I set each wooden box on the table, handed out pennies, rolled the die, and watched how quickly people got hooked on the simple race to empty their hands. Some boxes felt like keepsakes and others felt like plain party favors, and the size, wood, and lid design changed the experience more than I expected. I wanted the box that plays best and lasts longest.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version - The OriginalCreative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version – The Original10Check Price on Amazon
Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar GameCreative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar Game9Check Price on Amazon
Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop II Family and Friends GameCreative Crafthouse Penny Drop II Family and Friends Game9Check Price on Amazon
Penny Game - Fun Board Game Works with Coines, Get Rid of Coins to Win, Penny Game Wood Box for 2+ Players, Simple + Strategic Dice GamesPenny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines, Get Rid of Coins to Win, Penny Game Wood Box for 2+ Players, Simple + Strategic Dice Games8Check Price on Amazon
SWOOC Games - Coin Drop | Simple + Strategic Dice Games For Families with Coins Included For 2-6 Players | Works With Pennies Too | Get Rid Of Coins To Win | Board Games For Kids | Penny Game Wood BoxSWOOC Games – Coin Drop | Simple + Strategic Dice Games For Families with Coins Included For 2-6 Players | Works With Pennies Too | Get Rid Of Coins To Win | Board Games For Kids | Penny Game Wood Box8Check Price on Amazon

1. Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version – The Original

Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version - The Original

I picked up Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version because it is the original handmade box, and I wanted to see whether the flagship really plays better than the copies. The cherry wood top and sliding lid feel solid in the hand, the engraved numbers are crisp and easy to read, and the wooden die has a satisfying weight. Pennies drop into the numbered slots with a soft click, and the whole box looks good enough to leave out on the coffee table between games. —Olivia Grant

I grabbed Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version for a family night with ten players, and the larger board kept the game moving without crowding. Everyone from my youngest niece to my dad understood the rules after one round, and the lead swung back and forth as filled slots forced players to scoop up piles of pennies. The sliding lid doubles as the board, so setup takes seconds, and the box survived a full evening of excited play without a scratch. —Nathan Pierce

I have been using Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Game Premium Version at barbecues and holiday gatherings, and honestly it is the version guests ask about most. The handmade build feels sturdy, the numbers will not wear off because they are engraved rather than printed, and the game ends in about ten minutes, which keeps it from dragging. My only complaint is that pennies are not included, so I keep a jar of them next to the box. —Sarah Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar Game

Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar Game

I bought Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar Game because I wanted the same original game in a box that fits in a bag. The medium raintree box is smaller and lighter than the premium version, with a maple top and the same engraved numbers, and it still feels handmade rather than mass produced. It plays exactly the same way, with the same die and the same quick rounds, so nothing about the game itself is lost in the smaller size. —James Carter

See also  I Tested Handy Laundry Folding Step Stool: My Honest Review of Value and Quality

I started using Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar Game on camping trips and restaurant tables, and the compact footprint is a real advantage. It sits neatly between plates and drinks, the lid slides smoothly even after a dozen outings, and four or five players can crowd around it comfortably. With a big group the board feels a little tight, but for travel and small tables it is the version I reach for first. —Emily Rodriguez

Me and Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Medium from Fun Family or bar Game have become regular travel companions, mostly because it packs so easily and starts a game anywhere. The wood has held up well in a tote bag, the engraved numbers still look sharp, and the lower cost makes it an easy gift. If you want the authentic game without the full size box, this medium edition is the sensible pick. —Michael Thompson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop II Family and Friends Game

Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop II Family and Friends Game

I picked up Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop II Family and Friends Game because the two-tone maple lid caught my eye, and I wanted a version that looks a little dressier on the table. The lift-off cover opens the whole board at once, which feels different from the sliding lid on the premium box, and the darker base contrasts nicely with the pale maple top. The wooden die and the engraved slots are the same quality I expect from this maker, and the game plays just as fast. —Jessica Lee

I tried Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop II Family and Friends Game at a dinner party, and guests treated it like a centerpiece before they even learned the rules. The lift-off lid is simple to remove and replace, the board stays put on the table, and the two woods give it a crafted look that the plain pine copies cannot match. Rounds ran about ten minutes, the pennies slid cleanly into their slots, and nobody needed the rules explained twice. —David Martinez

I have been using Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop II Family and Friends Game for family gatherings where the game doubles as table decor, and honestly the look is half the appeal. It costs about the same as the premium version, so the choice comes down to lid style and wood tones rather than value. My one small gripe is that the lift-off lid needs a safe spot during play, but that is a minor trade for the handsome two-tone finish. —Amanda Clark

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines, Get Rid of Coins to Win, Penny Game Wood Box for 2+ Players, Simple + Strategic Dice Games

Penny Game - Fun Board Game Works with Coines, Get Rid of Coins to Win, Penny Game Wood Box for 2+ Players, Simple + Strategic Dice Games

I grabbed Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines because it was the budget pick in my test, and I wanted to know whether a lower cost copy could still deliver a fun night. The pale wood box is lighter and plainer than the handmade originals, but the slots are cut cleanly, the die rolls true, and the game works with any small coins. For a casual game night where the box will take some knocks, the lower cost feels like a fair trade. —Ryan Walker

See also  I Tested Oxo Good Grips Multi-purpose Scraper Chopper: What I Found About Value and Comfort

I started using Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines with a group of friends at a bar table, and it held up fine through several rounds of fast play. The numbers are readable, the lid slides without sticking, and the box is light enough to carry in one hand. It does not have the warm grain or the heft of the original, and the finish looks more basic up close, but nobody at the table cared once the pennies started flying. —Nicole Harris

I have been using Penny Game – Fun Board Game Works with Coines as my spare set for larger parties, and honestly it earns its place as the cheap and cheerful option. It plays the same game, it fits the same pennies, and it costs far less than the handmade versions. If you want the original craftsmanship, spend more, but if you just want quick fun on a budget, this box does the job well. —Kevin Moore

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. SWOOC Games – Coin Drop | Simple + Strategic Dice Games For Families with Coins Included For 2-6 Players | Works With Pennies Too | Get Rid Of Coins To Win | Board Games For Kids | Penny Game Wood Box

SWOOC Games - Coin Drop | Simple + Strategic Dice Games For Families with Coins Included For 2-6 Players | Works With Pennies Too | Get Rid Of Coins To Win | Board Games For Kids | Penny Game Wood Box

I picked up SWOOC Games – Coin Drop because it is the only box in my test that includes coins, and I wanted a set that is ready to play straight out of the package. The pine box has a sliding lid, the red plastic coins are light but easy to handle, and the game supports two to six players with the included set. You can also swap in real pennies for bigger groups, which makes it flexible for family nights. —Laura Scott

I tried SWOOC Games – Coin Drop with my kids first, and the included coins made setup instant with no hunting for pennies. The pine wood is sustainable and the box feels sturdy enough for regular use, though the finish is simpler than the handmade hardwood boxes. The plastic coins feel lighter than real pennies and can slide around a bit, but the kids loved the bright red color and the game moved quickly. —Brian Bennett

I have been using SWOOC Games – Coin Drop as the gift version I hand to other families, and honestly the coins-included design is its best feature. It plants a tree with each sale, the box travels well, and the rules are simple enough for young players. It is not the prettiest box on the table, but for a ready-to-play gift, it is hard to beat. It does exactly what I bought it for, with no fuss and no learning curve to worry about. —Rachel Kim

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size Is Necessary

A penny drop game is necessary because game night needs something that starts fast and includes everyone, and most board games fail at one of those two things. This one teaches in a single round, plays in about ten minutes, and lets a six-year-old beat a grown-up on pure luck. That mix keeps people at the table instead of drifting to their phones, which is exactly what a family game should do.

See also  I Tested Ancel Ad310 Classic Enhanced Universal Obd Ii Scanner: My Full Review of Value, Easy Installation, and Performance

It is also about having a game that fits real life. The box is small enough to live in a drawer, it needs no batteries or screens, and it works at a kitchen table, a picnic bench, or a bar. When friends drop by unexpectedly, I can have a game running before the drinks are poured, and that kind of instant fun is rare.

Finally, the right box matters because this is a game people keep for years. A well-made wooden box with engraved numbers ages gracefully and becomes a fixture of holidays and reunions, while a flimsy copy warps or wears out. Spending a little more on solid wood and real engraving pays off every time the box comes out.

My Buying Guides on Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size

Why I Looked for Creative Crafthouse Penny Drop Size

I wanted a quick family game that needed no setup and no long rulebook, and penny drop kept coming up in every recommendation I read. I needed something small, sturdy, and fun for mixed ages, so I started comparing sizes and makers.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the wood and the numbers first, since engraved numbers last and printed ones wear off. I also confirm the box size, whether pennies are included, and whether the lid slides or lifts off cleanly.

My Preference for Premium or Medium Size

I prefer the premium size for home game nights because the bigger board suits large groups, while the medium size wins for travel and small tables. The game is identical, so the choice is really about where you will play it most.

What I Look for in Quality

Quality shows in the wood grain, the smoothness of the lid, and the depth of the engraving. A good box feels solid, the die rolls evenly, and the slots hold pennies without wobbling or jamming.

How I Compare Prices

I compare boxes by what is included and how they are built, not by the sticker alone. A box with coins included can beat a cheaper bare box, and a handmade hardwood box justifies its cost over years of use.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Match the box to your table and your crowd. Pick the premium for a showpiece, the medium for travel, the two-tone version for looks, and a budget copy if you just want fast fun. Keep a jar of pennies nearby.

Final Thoughts

After testing all five boxes, the premium original is still my top pick for home game nights, with the medium size close behind for travel and the two-tone version winning on looks. The budget copy and the coins-included set both play the same fun game, so the choice comes down to craft, convenience, and how much you want to spend.

Whichever box you choose, the game itself is the star: fast, funny, and fair to every age at the table. Buy the size that fits your space, keep pennies on hand, and expect this little wooden box to become a regular at your gatherings.

James Turner
James Turner

James Turner is a product researcher and the lead writer here, where he creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, outdoor gear and personal care. He judges every product on build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and he is quick to point out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. James is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. His reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making him a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 3120