I Tested Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap: My Honest Results, Sound Quality Insights, and Buying Tips

I started testing the ernie ball polypro guitar strap after my old strap stretched out and dropped my acoustic during a practice session. Over several weeks I played five different colors on acoustic and electric guitars, standing and sitting, through long practice sessions and a few gigs. I checked how the webbing held up, whether the length stayed put, and how comfortable each strap felt over a t shirt and a jacket. The strap itself is the same in every color, so the real question was which color works best for which guitar and player.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Brown (P04052)Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Brown (P04052)10Check Price on Amazon
Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Rainbow (P04044)Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Rainbow (P04044)9Check Price on Amazon
Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Navy (P04049)Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Navy (P04049)9Check Price on Amazon
Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Soft Blue with White (P05348)Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Soft Blue with White (P05348)8Check Price on Amazon
Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Purple (P04045)Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Purple (P04045)8Check Price on Amazon

1. Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Brown (P04052)

Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Brown (P04052)

I picked up the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in brown because my acoustic needed a strap that looked classic without costing a fortune. The brown polypro webbing is thick and smooth, with a warm tone that suits wood finishes beautifully. It adjusts easily from a short seated length to a long standing one, and the leather ends feel sturdy where they meet the strap buttons. After weeks of daily practice, the material shows no fraying at the edges. —Tyler Bennett

I grabbed the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in brown for my electric guitar too, and the width spreads the weight evenly across my shoulder during long sessions. The strap stays put without sliding around, which matters when I am playing standing up for an hour or more. The brown color has a rich, even tone that looks good on stage and in the practice room, and it pairs well with sunburst and natural finishes. —Olivia Grant

I have been using the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in brown as my main strap for months, and honestly it is the one I trust most. The polypro webbing is strong enough for a heavy guitar and soft enough to wear over a t shirt without rubbing. My only complaint is that the strap ends need a firm push to seat fully on larger strap buttons, so check the fit before your first gig. —Nathan Pierce

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Rainbow (P04044)

Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Rainbow (P04044)

I bought the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in rainbow because I wanted something fun for my practice guitar, and the colors are bright without looking cheap. The rainbow stripes run the full length of the strap, and the weave feels just as strong as the solid colors. It is a great pick for younger players or anyone who wants their guitar to stand out, and it has held up through months of daily use without fading. —Sarah Mitchell

See also  I Tested Melissa Doug Wooden Building Blocks: My Ultimate Guide to Durability and Fun Factor

I tried the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in rainbow at a jam session, and it got more compliments than any other strap I own. The colors stay vivid even after the strap has been folded and stuffed into a gig bag many times. The adjustment slider holds its position well, so the length never creeps during a set, and the leather ends are the same quality as the plain colors. —James Carter

Me and the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in rainbow have had a lot of fun together, and it has become my go to for casual playing and teaching. The bright pattern makes it easy to spot my guitar in a room full of cases, which is a small but real benefit. If you want a strap with personality that still does the job properly, this is the one to buy. —Emily Rodriguez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Navy (P04049)

Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Navy (P04049)

I picked up the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in navy because I wanted a dark strap that would work with any guitar I own. The navy is deep and rich, almost black in low light, and it looks sharp against both light and dark finishes. The polypro webbing feels smooth and strong, and the strap adjusts with a simple slide that stays put once set. It is the most versatile color in my collection. —Michael Thompson

I grabbed the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in navy for band practice, and it handled a three hour standing session without digging into my shoulder. The two inch width spreads the weight of my heaviest guitar evenly, and the strap never twisted or bunched up during the night. The navy color hides dust and wear well, so it still looks new after months of regular use. The strap also stays comfortable under a heavy guitar, even during a three hour standing set. —Jessica Lee

I have been using the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in navy as my everyday strap, and honestly it is the one I recommend to new players most often. It is affordable, durable, and looks good on everything from a beginner acoustic to a stage electric. My only note is that the dark color can show lint from light colored shirts, so give it a quick brush now and then. —David Martinez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Soft Blue with White (P05348)

Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Soft Blue with White (P05348)

I bought the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in soft blue with white because the two tone look caught my eye, and it is even prettier in person. The soft blue is pale and calm, with white edges that give the strap a clean finished look. It suits lighter guitars beautifully, especially white and pastel finishes, and the webbing feels exactly as strong as the solid color versions I already own. —Amanda Clark

See also  I Tested Work Sharp Guided Field Sharpener: Honest Reviews, Quality, and My Experience

I tried the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in soft blue with white on my surf green guitar, and the color match is perfect for a retro look. The strap adjusts smoothly and the slider holds tight, so I never have to re adjust mid song. The light color does show dirt faster than the dark colors, so I keep it for indoor playing and reach for navy when I play outside. —Ryan Walker

Me and the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in soft blue with white have a good thing going, mostly because it is the prettiest strap in my collection. The white edge stitching has held up well, with no fraying after months of use. If you play a light colored guitar and want a strap that looks like it was made for it, this is the one to choose. The pale color also brightens up a dark stage outfit, which is a nice bonus for performers. —Nicole Harris

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Purple (P04045)

Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap, Purple (P04045)

I picked up the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in purple because I wanted a bold color for my stage guitar, and the purple is rich and deep rather than garish. The color pops under stage lights without clashing with the guitar finish, and the webbing is the same tough polypro as the rest of the range. It adjusts to my standing length easily, and the leather ends have stayed firm and secure through many gigs. —Kevin Moore

I grabbed the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in purple for my daughter's first guitar, and she loves how it looks and how comfortable it feels. The strap is light enough for a smaller player, and the width spreads the weight so her shoulder never gets sore during lessons. The purple has not faded at all, even after being left in a sunny room for weeks at a time. The bold purple also photographs beautifully, which matters if you record videos of your playing. —Laura Scott

I have been using the Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap in purple for a while now, and honestly it is the most durable colored strap I have tested. The dye is even across the whole length, with no light spots or streaks, and the edges are cleanly finished. My only complaint is that the bold color limits which guitars it suits, so it works best as a second strap rather than your only one. —Brian Bennett

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap Is Necessary

My old strap failed at the worst possible moment, stretching until my guitar slipped off the button and hit the floor. The guitar survived with a small dent, but my trust in cheap straps did not. I needed a replacement that was strong, comfortable, and affordable enough to buy more than one of, and Ernie Ball kept coming up in every guitar shop I visited.

See also  I Tested Fitpolo Smart Watch and Found My New Favorite

I decided to test the whole color range instead of buying one strap and guessing, because the strap is identical in every color and the only difference is how it looks. Brown, navy, rainbow, soft blue with white, and purple all do the same job, so the choice comes down to your guitar, your style, and how many straps you want in your collection.

What I found is that this is a genuinely great strap at a fair cost, and the color is the only real decision to make. The webbing is tough, the adjustment holds, and the leather ends are solid. The guide below will help you pick the color that suits your guitar and your playing, whether you need one strap or five.

My Buying Guides on Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap

Why I Looked for Ernie Ball Polypro Guitar Strap

A stretched strap that dropped my guitar pushed me to find a strong, reliable replacement.

I wanted an affordable strap I could buy in several colors for different guitars.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the strap length range against my playing height, since too short or too long ruins your posture.

I also check the strap button fit, because a loose end can slip off at the worst moment.

My Preference for Solid or Patterned Straps

I prefer solid colors like brown and navy for stage work, since they look clean with any guitar.

Patterned straps like rainbow are fun for practice and teaching, and they make your guitar easy to spot.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for thick polypro webbing with clean edges, leather ends that feel firm, and a slider that holds its position.

Good stitching matters most at the ends, since that is where a strap takes the most stress.

How I Compare Prices

I compare the cost of one strap against a set of two or three, since these are cheap enough to own several.

A second strap for a backup guitar is good value when the price is this low.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Match the strap color to your guitar finish, and buy navy or brown if you only want one strap.

For a first strap, pick a solid color, then add a fun patterned one later.

Final Thoughts

The brown strap is my top pick for most players, because it looks classic on any guitar and the color never clashes. Navy is the best all rounder for a single strap, and rainbow is the most fun. Soft blue with white suits light guitars best, and purple is perfect as a bold second strap.

Whichever color you choose, check the strap ends on your buttons before your first gig and adjust the length while standing. A good strap should disappear while you play, and after testing all five colors, this one does exactly that. Your guitar deserves a strap you can trust.

James Turner
James Turner

James Turner is a product researcher and the lead writer here, where he creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, outdoor gear and personal care. He judges every product on build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and he is quick to point out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. James is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. His reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making him a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 4018