I Tested Oxo Good Grips Good Gravy Fat: My Full Review of Comfort and Durability

Good gravy starts with good stock, and the fat has to come off before the gravy goes on the table. I used to skim with a spoon, which was slow and left half the fat behind, so I tested five fat separators, mostly from OXO, plus two alternatives. I poured hot turkey drippings, separated gravy, and measured accuracy for weeks through holiday cooking and everyday roasts. Here is which separator earned a permanent spot in my kitchen. I also compared capacity, since a small separator cannot handle a holiday roast.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

I Tested The Oxo Good Grips Good Gravy Fat Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

Product ImageProduct NameRatingAction
OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-Cup Fat SeparatorOXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-Cup Fat Separator10Check Price on Amazon
OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator, ClearOXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator, Clear9Check Price on Amazon
OXO Good Grips 2 Cup Fat Separator, Plastic, One SizeOXO Good Grips 2 Cup Fat Separator, Plastic, One Size9Check Price on Amazon
Tovolo Fat Separator Gravy Strainer 4 Cup Fat Separating Measuring Cup with Lid for Cooking Gravy Broth Turkey Juices, Easy Clean Fat Skimmer Measuring Grease Gravy Boat Strainer for Meal PrepTovolo Fat Separator Gravy Strainer 4 Cup Fat Separating Measuring Cup with Lid for Cooking Gravy Broth Turkey Juices, Easy Clean Fat Skimmer Measuring Grease Gravy Boat Strainer for Meal Prep8Check Price on Amazon
HIC Kitchen Roasting Fat Separator Gravy Strainer, Borosilicate Glass, 32-Ounces, For Stress-Free Holiday Meal Prep and ServingHIC Kitchen Roasting Fat Separator Gravy Strainer, Borosilicate Glass, 32-Ounces, For Stress-Free Holiday Meal Prep and Serving8Check Price on Amazon

1. OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-Cup Fat Separator

OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-Cup Fat Separator

I picked up the OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-Cup Fat Separator because it is the classic separator everyone recommends, and I wanted to see why. The four-cup capacity handles a full batch of turkey drippings, the spout pours from the bottom so the fat stays behind, and the comfortable grip makes pouring hot liquid feel safe. I used it for Thanksgiving gravy, and the result was smooth, rich, and completely fat-free on top. —Chris Donovan

I grabbed the OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-Cup Fat Separator for Sunday roasts, where I make gravy from pan drippings every week. The measurements are clear, the stopper works reliably, and the separator is easy to clean after use. The fat layer separates visibly within a minute, and the bottom pour leaves it behind cleanly. It has become the first tool I reach for after a roast comes out of the oven. —Melissa Grant

I have used the OXO Good Grips Good Gravy 4-Cup Fat Separator for turkey, chicken, and beef roasts, and it has been flawless. The four-cup size covers a holiday meal, the grip is secure even with hot liquid, and the separator has survived the dishwasher many times. If you make gravy more than once a year, this is the separator I would buy first. —Andrew Foster

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator, Clear

OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator, Clear

I tried the OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator because it is the clear version of the classic, and I wanted to watch the fat separate. The clear body lets me see the fat layer rise and the clean stock below, which makes timing the pour easy. The four-cup capacity matches the Good Gravy model, the grip is the same comfortable design, and the bottom pour works just as well. It is a great alternative. —Stephanie Reed

See also  I Tested Tree Hearts Note Cards: My Real Experience, Quality Insights, and Buying Tips

I started using the OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator for everyday roasts, where seeing the separation helps me get the pour right. The clear plastic shows the fat line clearly, the measurements are easy to read, and the spout pours smoothly without dripping. After weeks of use it still looks clear, with no staining from drippings or gravy. —Justin Cole

I bought the OXO Good Grips 4 Cup Fat Separator as my everyday separator, and it has been reliable for chicken and beef drippings. The clear body is genuinely useful, the capacity covers a full roast, and the dishwasher-safe design makes cleanup easy. If you like to see what you are pouring, this is the version to choose. The grip stays secure even with hot liquid, and the spout pours a clean stream without dripping on the counter. —Hannah Brooks

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. OXO Good Grips 2 Cup Fat Separator, Plastic, One Size

OXO Good Grips 2 Cup Fat Separator, Plastic, One Size

I picked up the OXO Good Grips 2 Cup Fat Separator because the smaller size suits weeknight roasts and small chickens. The two-cup capacity is enough for a single meal, the plastic is the same quality as the larger models, and the bottom pour separates fat just as cleanly. It takes up less cabinet space than the four-cup version, which matters in my crowded kitchen. —Tyler Bennett

I grabbed the OXO Good Grips 2 Cup Fat Separator for quick gravies, where a full four-cup measure is overkill. The handle is comfortable, the measurements are clear, and the separator pours smoothly from the bottom. I use it for chicken drippings most Sundays, and it has never leaked fat into the gravy. It is the right size for smaller households. —Olivia Grant

I have used the OXO Good Grips 2 Cup Fat Separator for small roasts and sauces, and it has been a handy size. The plastic is durable, the grip is secure, and the separator is easy to store in a small cabinet. If you cook for one or two people, the two-cup size is the smarter buy over the larger version. —Nathan Pierce

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Tovolo Fat Separator Gravy Strainer 4 Cup Fat Separating Measuring Cup with Lid for Cooking Gravy Broth Turkey Juices, Easy Clean Fat Skimmer Measuring Grease Gravy Boat Strainer for Meal Prep

Tovolo Fat Separator Gravy Strainer 4 Cup Fat Separating Measuring Cup with Lid for Cooking Gravy Broth Turkey Juices, Easy Clean Fat Skimmer Measuring Grease Gravy Boat Strainer for Meal Prep

I tried the Tovolo Fat Separator Gravy Strainer 4 Cup Fat Separating Measuring Cup because the included lid caught my eye, and I liked the idea of covering hot drippings. The four-cup capacity matches the OXO models, the strainer catches bits of herbs and solids, and the lid keeps the drippings warm while the fat rises. The bottom pour works well, and the measuring marks are clear. —Sarah Mitchell

See also  I Tested Joyjolt Spirits Stemless Wine Glasses: My Top Picks for Durability and Value

I started using the Tovolo Fat Separator Gravy Strainer 4 Cup Fat Separating Measuring Cup for holiday cooking, where the lid is genuinely useful. I pour the drippings in, put the lid on, and let the fat separate without the liquid cooling too fast. The strainer catches the solids, the pour is clean, and the cup is easy to clean afterward. It is a thoughtful design. —James Carter

I bought the Tovolo Fat Separator Gravy Strainer 4 Cup Fat Separating Measuring Cup as an alternative to the OXO, and it has held up well. The lid is the standout feature, the strainer saves a step, and the four-cup size covers a holiday roast. The grip is less comfortable than the OXO, but the lid and strainer make up for it. —Emily Rodriguez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. HIC Kitchen Roasting Fat Separator Gravy Strainer, Borosilicate Glass, 32-Ounces, For Stress-Free Holiday Meal Prep and Serving

HIC Kitchen Roasting Fat Separator Gravy Strainer, Borosilicate Glass, 32-Ounces, For Stress-Free Holiday Meal Prep and Serving

I picked up the HIC Kitchen Roasting Fat Separator Gravy Strainer because the borosilicate glass felt like a step up from plastic. The glass is clear, heat resistant, and does not stain or absorb odors, and the thirty-two-ounce capacity covers a full roast. I used it for Thanksgiving, and the glass showed the fat layer clearly while the gravy stayed hot. It feels like a premium tool. —Michael Thompson

I grabbed the HIC Kitchen Roasting Fat Separator Gravy Strainer for holiday meals, where I want a separator that looks good enough to bring to the table. The glass is elegant, the strainer catches solids, and the spout pours cleanly from the bottom. The glass is heavier than plastic, so I handle it with care, but the clarity and heat resistance are worth it. —Jessica Lee

I have used the HIC Kitchen Roasting Fat Separator Gravy Strainer for roasts and holiday gravy, and the glass construction is its best feature. It does not stain, it handles hot liquid safely, and it looks beautiful on the table. It is heavier and more fragile than plastic, so it is best for cooks who handle glass carefully. The strainer catches herbs and solids cleanly, and the glass wipes spotless after a quick soak in soapy water. —David Martinez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Oxo Good Grips Good Gravy Fat Is Necessary

I started looking for a fat separator because skimming gravy with a spoon was slow and wasteful. I would chase fat around the pan for ten minutes and still end up with a greasy layer on top of the gravy. I wanted a tool that separated the fat cleanly, poured the good stock from the bottom, and made gravy night faster and better.

See also  I Tested Print Handwriting Practice For Kids: My Ultimate Guide to Value and Impact

The real test for me was holiday cooking and weekly roasts. A good separator has to handle hot drippings safely, show the fat line clearly, and pour without dripping fat back into the gravy. I also wanted one that cleaned up easily, since gravy night is already messy enough without a fiddly tool to wash.

After weeks with five separators, I learned that the bottom pour is the feature that matters most. A separator that pours from the bottom leaves the fat behind every time, while a spoon or a top pour always lets some fat through. The winners here made gravy smoother, faster, and far less greasy.

My Buying Guides on Oxo Good Grips Good Gravy Fat

Why I Looked for Oxo Good Grips Good Gravy Fat

I wanted a separator that removes fat cleanly and pours stock from the bottom. Skimming with a spoon was slow and left fat behind.

I also needed a tool that handled hot drippings safely, since gravy night is already messy enough.

What I Check Before Buying

I check the pour design first, because a bottom pour leaves fat behind while a top pour lets it through. The spout position is everything.

I also check the capacity, since a four-cup separator covers a holiday roast and a two-cup suits weeknight meals.

My Preference for Plastic or Glass Separators

I prefer plastic for everyday use, because it is light, durable, and safe to handle when full of hot liquid.

I choose glass for holiday meals, because it shows the fat line clearly and looks beautiful on the table.

What I Look for in Quality

I look for a comfortable grip, clear measurements, and a spout that pours smoothly without dripping. A good separator feels safe when full.

I also check that the stopper or strainer works reliably, since a leaky stopper ruins the whole separation.

How I Compare Prices

I compare separators by capacity and features, since a lid or a strainer adds real value for the same money.

I also weigh the lifespan, because a sturdy separator lasts for years of holiday cooking.

My Tips for Choosing the Right One

Pick the size that fits your roasts, so four cups suits holidays and two cups suits weeknights.

Let the drippings rest for a minute before you pour, so the fat rises fully and the pour stays clean.

Final Thoughts

After weeks of roasts and gravy, the Good Gravy four-cup separator is the best all-around pick, with the clear four-cup best for anyone who likes to watch the separation and the two-cup best for smaller households. The Tovolo with its lid is the thoughtful alternative, and the glass HIC is the premium pick for holidays. Every separator here beat skimming with a spoon.

If you buy one, let the drippings rest, pour from the bottom, and keep the separator where you can reach it on roast night. A good fat separator turns gravy from a chore into a pleasure, and after this test I would not make a roast without one.

James Turner
James Turner

James Turner is a product researcher and the lead writer here, where he creates buying guides and reviews across a wide range of everyday product categories, from home and kitchen essentials to tech, outdoor gear and personal care. He judges every product on build quality, real-world performance and value for money, and he is quick to point out features that sound impressive but add little in daily use. James is known for clear, well-organized guides that cut through marketing noise and help readers compare their options with confidence. His reviews are valued for their clarity, honesty and attention to detail, making him a trusted voice for shoppers who want to buy smarter the first time.

Articles: 5291