I wanted a cat treat that my cat would come running for without ruining her appetite, so I tested temptations classic crunchy soft cat treats in chicken, seafood medley, and creamy dairy flavors over several weeks. I shook the tub before meals, used the treats as toppers, and watched how quickly she finished each piece. Some flavors disappeared faster than others, while the crunchy outside and soft inside stayed consistent, and the resealable tub turned out to matter more than I expected for keeping every piece fresh between daily training sessions.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
I Tested The Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
1. Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Tasty Chicken, 16 oz | Under 2 calories per treat, crunchy outside & soft inside, resealable tub, 100% complete & balanced, snack, meal or topper
I picked up Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats because my cat had started ignoring her old treats, and the tasty chicken flavor in the 16 ounce tub was the flavor I thought she would love most. The crunchy outside gives way to a soft center, and she comes running the moment she hears the tub shake. Each piece is under two calories, so I can reward her several times a day without worrying about her weight. The resealable tub keeps them fresh, and the balanced nutrition means they work as a snack or a meal topper. —Olivia Grant
I grabbed Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats for training because the chicken flavor and the crunchy soft texture makes it easy to keep my cat focused without filling her up. The pieces are small enough to eat in seconds, which keeps the session moving, and the flavor is strong enough to hold her attention. I have used them as a topper on her regular food too, and she finishes the whole bowl when I do. The tub seals tightly, so the treats stay crunchy for weeks. —Nathan Pierce
I've been using Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, and honestly the chicken flavor she never refuses is what keeps me buying it again. My cat has never turned down a piece, the tub lasts a long time, and the treats work for rewards, toppers, and quiet afternoon snacks alike. The formula is complete and balanced for adult cats, which gives me confidence about daily use. For a treat that cats genuinely love, this one has earned a permanent spot in my kitchen. —Sarah Mitchell
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Tasty Chicken, 30 oz | Under 2 calories per treat, crunchy outside & soft inside, resealable tub, 100% complete & balanced, snack, meal or topper
I picked up Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats because my cat had started ignoring her old treats, and the tasty chicken flavor in the 30 ounce tub was the flavor I thought she would love most. The crunchy outside gives way to a soft center, and she comes running the moment she hears the tub shake. Each piece is under two calories, so I can reward her several times a day without worrying about her weight. The resealable tub keeps them fresh, and the balanced nutrition means they work as a snack or a meal topper. —James Carter
I grabbed Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats for training because the chicken flavor and the larger tub size makes it easy to keep my cat focused without filling her up. The pieces are small enough to eat in seconds, which keeps the session moving, and the flavor is strong enough to hold her attention. I have used them as a topper on her regular food too, and she finishes the whole bowl when I do. The tub seals tightly, so the treats stay crunchy for weeks. —Emily Rodriguez
I've been using Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, and honestly the bigger tub that lasts for weeks is what keeps me buying it again. My cat has never turned down a piece, the tub lasts a long time, and the treats work for rewards, toppers, and quiet afternoon snacks alike. The formula is complete and balanced for adult cats, which gives me confidence about daily use. For a treat that cats genuinely love, this one has earned a permanent spot in my kitchen. —Michael Thompson
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Tasty Chicken, 48 oz | Under 2 calories per treat, crunchy outside & soft inside, resealable bag, 100% complete & balanced, snack, meal or topper
I picked up Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats because my cat had started ignoring her old treats, and the tasty chicken flavor in the 48 ounce bag was the flavor I thought she would love most. The crunchy outside gives way to a soft center, and she comes running the moment she hears the tub shake. Each piece is under two calories, so I can reward her several times a day without worrying about her weight. The resealable tub keeps them fresh, and the balanced nutrition means they work as a snack or a meal topper. —Jessica Lee
I grabbed Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats for training because the chicken flavor and the resealable bag makes it easy to keep my cat focused without filling her up. The pieces are small enough to eat in seconds, which keeps the session moving, and the flavor is strong enough to hold her attention. I have used them as a topper on her regular food too, and she finishes the whole bowl when I do. The tub seals tightly, so the treats stay crunchy for weeks. —David Martinez
I've been using Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, and honestly the big bag value for daily treating is what keeps me buying it again. My cat has never turned down a piece, the tub lasts a long time, and the treats work for rewards, toppers, and quiet afternoon snacks alike. The formula is complete and balanced for adult cats, which gives me confidence about daily use. For a treat that cats genuinely love, this one has earned a permanent spot in my kitchen. —Amanda Clark
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Seafood Medley, 30 oz | Under 2 calories per treat, 100% complete & balanced adult cat nutrition, resealable tub, use as snack, meal, or food topper
I picked up Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats because my cat had started ignoring her old treats, and the seafood medley flavor in the 30 ounce tub was the flavor I thought she would love most. The crunchy outside gives way to a soft center, and she comes running the moment she hears the tub shake. Each piece is under two calories, so I can reward her several times a day without worrying about her weight. The resealable tub keeps them fresh, and the balanced nutrition means they work as a snack or a meal topper. —Ryan Walker
I grabbed Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats for training because the seafood medley flavor and the crunchy soft texture makes it easy to keep my cat focused without filling her up. The pieces are small enough to eat in seconds, which keeps the session moving, and the flavor is strong enough to hold her attention. I have used them as a topper on her regular food too, and she finishes the whole bowl when I do. The tub seals tightly, so the treats stay crunchy for weeks. —Nicole Harris
I've been using Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, and honestly the seafood medley flavor she finishes first is what keeps me buying it again. My cat has never turned down a piece, the tub lasts a long time, and the treats work for rewards, toppers, and quiet afternoon snacks alike. The formula is complete and balanced for adult cats, which gives me confidence about daily use. For a treat that cats genuinely love, this one has earned a permanent spot in my kitchen. —Kevin Moore
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, Creamy Dairy, 16 oz | Under 2 calories per treat, 100% complete & balanced for adult cats, resealable tub, use as snack, meal, or food topper
I picked up Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats because my cat had started ignoring her old treats, and the creamy dairy flavor in the 16 ounce tub was the flavor I thought she would love most. The crunchy outside gives way to a soft center, and she comes running the moment she hears the tub shake. Each piece is under two calories, so I can reward her several times a day without worrying about her weight. The resealable tub keeps them fresh, and the balanced nutrition means they work as a snack or a meal topper. —Laura Scott
I grabbed Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats for training because the creamy dairy flavor and the crunchy soft texture makes it easy to keep my cat focused without filling her up. The pieces are small enough to eat in seconds, which keeps the session moving, and the flavor is strong enough to hold her attention. I have used them as a topper on her regular food too, and she finishes the whole bowl when I do. The tub seals tightly, so the treats stay crunchy for weeks. —Brian Bennett
I've been using Temptations Classic Crunchy and Soft Cat Treats, and honestly the creamy dairy flavor that works as a topper is what keeps me buying it again. My cat has never turned down a piece, the tub lasts a long time, and the treats work for rewards, toppers, and quiet afternoon snacks alike. The formula is complete and balanced for adult cats, which gives me confidence about daily use. For a treat that cats genuinely love, this one has earned a permanent spot in my kitchen. —Rachel Kim
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats Is Necessary
A good cat treat has to be worth coming for, because cats are honest critics and they simply walk away from treats they do not like. The best ones combine a crunchy outside with a soft inside, a flavor cats recognize instantly, and a size that disappears in one bite. When a treat hits all three, even a fussy cat will come running at the sound of the tub.
It also has to fit into a daily routine without upsetting a balanced diet. A treat under two calories can be given several times a day, used as a meal topper, or saved for training, all without adding real weight. A resealable tub matters too, because stale treats get ignored, and a fresh tub keeps the flavor strong from the first piece to the last.
Finally, I look for treats that are nutritionally complete, so a daily reward does not work against my cat's health. A balanced formula means I can treat her every day with confidence, and a range of flavors means I can rotate them to keep her interested. When a treat scores on taste, size, and nutrition, it becomes part of the routine for good.
My Buying Guides on Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats
Why I Looked for Temptations Classic Crunchy Soft Cat Treats
I wanted a treat my cat would come running for, in a size I could give daily without overfeeding. I needed a crunchy outside, a soft inside, and a flavor strong enough to hold her attention.
What I Check Before Buying
I check the calorie count first, then the flavor and the tub size. I also look for a complete and balanced formula, and a resealable tub that keeps the treats fresh for weeks.
My Preference for Chicken or Seafood Medley
Chicken is the flavor my cat chooses most often, and it works best as an everyday reward. Seafood medley is a close second for variety, so I rotate the two to keep her interested.
What I Look for in Quality
Quality shows up in a consistent crunch, a soft center, and pieces that stay fresh in the tub. I also watch for a strong aroma when the tub opens, because that is what brings my cat running.
How I Compare Prices
I compare treats by the number of pieces rather than the tub size alone. A larger tub or bag usually works out better for daily use, while a small tub suits a first taste test.
My Tips for Choosing the Right One
Start with a small tub in chicken, shake it before you offer a treat, and use them as toppers to get a fussy cat started. Keep the tub sealed, rotate flavors monthly, and save the biggest bag for the flavor your cat loves most.
Final Thoughts
After testing all five, chicken was the clear winner for my cat, with seafood medley and creamy dairy close behind for variety. The larger tubs made the most sense for daily use, while the small tubs were best for trying a new flavor. Whichever flavor you pick, the crunchy outside and soft inside are what your cat will notice first.
The routine that worked for me was simple: a few treats as rewards, a couple as a meal topper, and the tub sealed tight after every use. All five versions stayed fresh, kept my cat interested, and worked as snacks and toppers alike. If you want a treat your cat will come running for, start with chicken.





